The Guns of Then and Now: A Showdown Between a Tricked-Out Colt/Wilson Combat/Swenson M1911 and the FNX-45 Tactical
From Swenson’s Masterpieces to Modern Tactical Powerhouses—A Deep Dive Into Two Iconic .45 ACP Pistols That Define Generations of Handgun Evolution, by Alex Bosschaerts
On a blistering afternoon at a South Houston range, I held two icons of the .45 ACP world: the timeless Colt/Wilson Combat M1911 with Swenson integrals, born of the golden age of custom gunsmithing, and the modern marvel, the FNX-45 Tactical. These two pistols represent vastly different eras in handgun design. The M1911, steeped in craftsmanship and history, captures an era where precision and art were paramount. The FNX-45 Tactical, however, brings innovation, adaptability, and firepower to the forefront of modern tactical handgun engineering. But when it comes to real-world performance, which one truly reigns supreme?
Historical Legacy vs. Modern Innovation
The M1911 Colt/Wilson Combat that I tested wasn’t just any 1911—it was a piece of history. Built on a Colt Series 70 frame from 1978, this particular model was part of an early, custom-ordered batch for Wilson Combat. As one of Wilson’s first major projects after their incorporation in 1977, this gun represented the company’s early efforts in refining and customizing the already legendary platform. Despite a fire that destroyed much of Wilson Combat’s early records, the historical weight of this 1978 build is undeniable 1911 Forum.
But this gun’s significance goes deeper. Armand Swenson, one of the most respected names in 1911 gunsmithing, left his indelible mark on the platform. Swenson pioneered many of the features that are now standard on custom 1911s, including the square trigger guard for better support-hand grip and 30 lpi checkering on the front strap to improve control during rapid fire. These features, alongside Swenson’s famous barrel fitting, which include ambidextrous thumb safeties and the S&W K-frame rear sights, reinforced to prevent shearing during recoil, and attention to detail ensured that this M1911 offered a perfect balance between bullseye accuracy and combat reliability. An Official Journal Of The NRA.
In contrast, the FNX-45 Tactical is built for the modern shooter. It boasts a 15+1 round double-stack magazine, dwarfing the M1911’s 7-round capacity, and comes optics-ready with a Trijicon RM08G RMR mounted on the slide. Paired with a Viridian X5L laser-light combo, the FNX is all about rapid target acquisition and adaptability, especially in tactical or low-light scenarios. The FNX takes John Browning’s original .45 ACP platform into the future, offering higher capacity and modern features without compromising on the stopping power for which the round is known Pew Pew Tactical 1911 Forum.
Shooting Experience: Precision Meets Power
Both pistols performed flawlessly across multiple ammo types, including steel-cased and brass-cased, as well as 200gr and 230gr loads. There were no malfunctions, proving both guns reliable in various conditions.
Shooting the FNX-45 Tactical was an absolute pleasure. The Viridian X5L adds a comforting weight to the front of the gun, reducing muzzle rise, and keeping me on target during rapid fire. The Trijicon RMR, aligned perfectly with the laser at 20 yards, made target acquisition seamless—even under challenging lighting conditions. This setup, although costly (with the Trijicon around $680 and the Viridian X5L at $300), proves invaluable for tactical use or home defense situations, where quick, accurate follow-up shots matter Pew Pew Tactical The Truth About Guns.
By comparison, the M1911, enhanced with Swenson's ergonomics and internals, delivered a different kind of shooting experience—one rooted in history and precision. The single-action trigger was crisp, offering a perfect break with each shot. While I was grouping in the 3-4 inch range, which is respectable but not quite up to par with what this gun is capable of, an expert shooter would have no problem getting sub-2-inch groups out of this piece. The M1911’s heavier steel frame soaked up recoil like a sponge, offering a smooth, deliberate shooting experience that was truly enjoyable An Official Journal Of The NRA 1911 Forum.
Recoil and Muzzle Flip: Tradition vs. Modern Compensations
The FNX-45 Tactical’s polymer frame naturally comes with a bit more recoil compared to the M1911’s all-steel construction. However, the added weight of the Viridian X5L at the muzzle, along with the balanced feel of the Trijicon RMR, helped mitigate that recoil, keeping the muzzle flip in check. The result was faster follow-up shots and tighter control, particularly in rapid-fire situations where multiple rounds needed to be sent downrange quickly The Truth About Guns Pew Pew Tactical.
The M1911, with its heavier construction and Swenson’s barrel positioner technology, handled the .45 ACP recoil with ease. Although it doesn’t have the quickfire capabilities of the FNX, its slower, methodical recoil management made it easy to keep on target, even when using heavier 230gr rounds. The pistol’s Swenson modifications, including the squared trigger guard, front compensator features, and textured grip, provided better ergonomics, further enhancing its already smooth handling 1911 Forum An Official Journal Of The NRA.
Real-World Applications: BBQ Gun vs. Tactical Workhorse
Both pistols performed flawlessly across multiple ammo types, including steel-cased and brass-cased, as well as 200gr and 230gr loads. There were no misfeeds or malfunctions, proving both guns to be reliable across various conditions.
However, in terms of real-world application, the M1911 feels like the perfect BBQ gun—something you’d show off for its history, craftsmanship, and unmatched precision. The combination of Wilson Combat’s refinements and Swenson’s legacy of innovation make it a rare and valuable piece, both on the range and in historical significance An Official Journal Of The NRA 1911 Forum.
On the other hand, the FNX-45 Tactical is the gun I’d reach for in a defensive scenario or as a truck/ranch gun. Its higher capacity, tactical accessories, and quick target acquisition make it ideal for home defense or for situations where rapid response is needed. It’s a modern-day workhorse, built to perform in dynamic environments where capacity and quick shooting matter most Pew Pew Tactical 1911 Forum.
IDPA Standards: Outside the Box
Interestingly, both pistols wouldn’t meet today’s IDPA (International Defensive Pistol Association) standards, which have evolved to focus on more compact, lower-capacity pistols for practical shooting. The M1911, once the gold standard for competition shooters, no longer fits the size and capacity requirements, particularly with its single-stack magazine. Likewise, the FNX-45 Tactical—with its large double-stack magazine and suppressor-ready features—also falls outside the box for IDPA use 1911 Forum. This shows just how far both firearms push beyond the limitations of practical competition standards, excelling in areas that make them ideal for other purposes, like self-defense and tactical roles.
Conclusion: A Pair of Legends
In the end, the M1911 Colt/Wilson Combat, with its combination of Swenson’s groundbreaking modifications and Wilson Combat’s early craftsmanship, is a relic of a bygone era—an era that valued precision and craftsmanship above all else. While it may no longer be the gold standard in competition circles like IDPA, its historical significance and superb accuracy make it a gun that’s just as valuable today as it was fifty years ago. It’s the perfect BBQ gun—a work of art that you take to the range when you want to shoot something that feels personal, refined, and timeless.
On the other hand, the FNX-45 Tactical is the handgun I’d trust in a high-pressure situation. With its 15-round capacity, modern optics, and quick handling, it’s built for today’s world. Whether for home defense or as a truck gun, the FNX excels in scenarios that demand rapid target acquisition and adaptability. Both guns are workhorses in their own right, pushing the boundaries of what a .45 ACP handgun can do—whether you're honoring the past or embracing the future.
For those in the market:
FNX-45 Tactical: Prices range from around $1,200 to $1,400, offering unparalleled tactical flexibility.
Colt M1911: Depending on the model, you’ll find them from $800 to $1,500 +, with higher-end models and custom builds exceeding those numbers Guns.com The Truth About Guns.
Ultimately, both pistols give you the stopping power of the .45 ACP, but with different flavors of performance. Whether you’re looking for modern tech or vintage reliability, there’s no wrong choice between these two legends. FIN.
Fuel the Stories That Connect Us
When you become a paid subscriber to Bosschaerts Study, you're not just supporting a platform—you’re fueling the stories that spark curiosity and ignite conversations. Your contribution directly powers the creative energy that allows me, Alex Bosschaerts, to continue crafting unique, thought-provoking narratives. Whether it’s a deep-dive gun review or explorations like Nvidia’s AI Revolution: From Graphics to Global Domination, or the captivating weekly series ¿Esta noche no, o sí?, your support ensures that these stories remain accessible for everyone to ponder, discuss, and share.
Your subscription means more than just keeping the lights on. It's an investment in a creative journey that we embark on together. With your help, we can continue building a space where storytelling thrives, new ideas take shape, and meaningful connections flourish. Thank you for being part of this community and for empowering the stories that inspire us all.
Welcome to the Bosschaerts Lounge for The Guns of Then and Now in .45 ACP
This curated experience is designed to deepen your understanding of the evolution of the .45 ACP platform, from the craftsmanship of the Colt/Wilson Combat M1911 to the cutting-edge tactical precision of the FNX-45 Tactical. As we explore the themes of craftsmanship, innovation, and tactical adaptability, we offer thoughtful pairings—drinks, music, and reflections—to enhance your reading journey and immerse you in the culture of firearms and their impact on history and performance.
Reflections on the Evolution of the .45 ACP
In The Guns of Then and Now, we explore the journey of the .45 ACP platform, starting with the custom-built Colt/Wilson Combat M1911 enhanced by Armand Swenson’s craftsmanship. This model encapsulates an era of precision and custom modifications, a time when gunsmithing was as much about art as function. The narrative continues with the FNX-45 Tactical, a modern tactical powerhouse equipped for rapid response, higher capacity, and adaptability, offering a stark contrast to the classic, all-steel M1911. These pistols showcase how innovation and tactical needs drive the evolution of firearm design.
This story challenges us to reflect on the balance between tradition and modernity. While the M1911 remains a collector’s favorite, the FNX-45 Tactical symbolizes the needs of today’s defense-focused shooter. Each firearm tells a story of its time and purpose, asking the reader to consider how form and function evolve over decades of innovation.
Vocabulary List
.45 ACP (Automatic Colt Pistol): A powerful handgun cartridge designed by John Browning in 1904, known for its stopping power and used extensively by military and law enforcement.
M1911: A semi-automatic pistol designed by John Browning in Hartford, Connecticut, and adopted by the U.S. Army in 1911. Renowned for its reliability and heavy .45 ACP round, it remains a favorite among enthusiasts.
Tactical Handgun: A firearm designed for modern defense and combat scenarios, typically featuring higher capacity, optics, and customizable parts for adaptability.
Swenson (Armand Swenson): A renowned gunsmith who pioneered many of the modern customizations found on the 1911, such as the square trigger guard, front strap checkering, and ambidextrous safety, revolutionizing the platform's ergonomics and accuracy.
Wilson Combat: An industry leader in custom firearms, founded in 1977 by Bill Wilson. Known for their top-tier 1911 builds, they set new standards in precision, reliability, and performance in the custom gun world.
FN (Fabrique Nationale): A Belgian firearms manufacturer with a rich history of producing firearms for military, law enforcement, and civilian markets. They are known for innovative designs, including the FNX-45 Tactical, which takes John Browning’s original .45 ACP concept into the future.
IDPA (International Defensive Pistol Association): A shooting sport that simulates self-defense scenarios, focusing on practical shooting skills under pressure. While the M1911 was once favored in IDPA competitions, modern tactical pistols like the FNX-45 Tactical often exceed the size and capacity limits set by the organization.
Trigger Guard: A part of the firearm that encircles the trigger, protecting it from accidental discharge. The square trigger guard on Swenson-customized M1911s enhances grip and control during rapid fire.
Barrel Bushing: A ring that supports the barrel in some handguns, contributing to accuracy by reducing barrel movement during firing.
Word Reflection: "Evolution"
The evolution of the .45 ACP platform is more than just technological progression—it’s about the changing needs of shooters over generations. From the rugged precision of the M1911, designed for reliability in combat, to the adaptable FNX-45 Tactical, built for today’s high-capacity tactical demands, this is a story of how firearms evolve to meet the needs of their time. Just as firearms adapt, so too do we as enthusiasts, appreciating both tradition and innovation in equal measure.
Book Pairings:
"American Gun: A History of the U.S. in Ten Firearms" by Chris Kyle
This book provides a historical perspective on firearms that shaped America, including the M1911. It’s an excellent companion to understanding how guns like the M1911 have not only defined warfare but also impacted American culture.
"The Gun" by C.J. Chivers
This deep dive into the history of the firearm traces its development and usage over time, with detailed accounts of both technological innovation and cultural impact—perfect for readers interested in how firearms like the FNX-45 Tactical are part of a longer lineage of innovation.
Beer Recommendation: Cold Tecate Lager with Lime and Salt
There’s no better companion for a day at the range or reflecting on the rugged power of the .45 ACP than a cold Tecate. Served straight from the can with a squeeze of fresh lime and a sprinkle of salt, it brings a refreshing balance to the heaviness of the .45 ACP platform—just as the FNX-45 Tactical balances tradition with modern innovation. The bold and uncomplicated flavor of Tecate Lager makes it a perfect match for appreciating the straightforward, dependable nature of both pistols.
Drink Recipe: The Tactical Classic
Inspired by the balance between tradition and modernity that the M1911 and FNX-45 Tactical represent, this cocktail blends old-world simplicity with a modern twist.
Ingredients:
1.5 oz bourbon (representing the classic M1911)
1 oz Cointreau
0.75 oz lemon juice
A dash of bitters
Garnish: orange peel twist
Instructions:
Combine bourbon, Cointreau, and lemon juice in a shaker with ice.
Shake well and strain into a glass with ice.
Add a dash of bitters and garnish with an orange peel twist.
This cocktail is a nod to the M1911’s classic status, with the modern twist of bitters representing the FNX-45 Tactical’s tactical adaptability. The balance of rich bourbon and the sharpness of citrus mirrors the balance between old-school craftsmanship and new-world innovation.
Music Recommendation: Johnny Cash - God's Gonna Cut You Down
This haunting track by Johnny Cash echoes the rugged and timeless quality of the M1911, while its gritty, direct lyrics reflect the no-nonsense power of the .45 ACP platform. Cash’s deep voice resonates with the legacy of precision, tradition, and unyielding strength that defines both the M1911 and its modern counterpart, the FNX-45 Tactical.
Closing Thoughts: Guns, Craftsmanship, and Evolution
As you sip a cold Tecate and reflect on The Guns of Then and Now in .45 ACP, consider how firearms, much like people, evolve in response to their environment and needs. The M1911 symbolizes the reliability and craftsmanship of its era, while the FNX-45 Tactical represents today’s demand for high-capacity, quick-fire versatility. Both pistols tell a story of their time, proving that evolution is not about replacement, but about adaptation.
Much like the evolution of firearms, Bosschaerts Study continues to adapt and grow—powered by stories, ideas, and the support of readers like you. Stay tuned for more curated experiences and deeper explorations. And remember, by becoming a paid subscriber, you are part of this journey, helping us create the stories that inspire and connect us all.
Thank you for joining us in the Bosschaerts Lounge, where tradition meets innovation, and every story takes you deeper into the craftsmanship that defines our world.
